Upper respiratory tract infections and academic attainment: A case study
Background: There has been extensive research showing that upper respiratory tract infections (URTIs), such as the common cold and influenza, can impair mental performance. Much of this research has involved studies of experimentally induced URTIs or laboratory studies of naturally occurring illnesses. The results from this research have implications for performance at work and in education.
Aims: The present article presents a case study of the association between URTIs and academic performance and reports the use of such information as an extenuating circumstance for poor performance.
Methods: The paper describes the poor performance of a primary school student taking the 11+ examination, which determines the choice of the future secondary school. Evidence suggested that it was plausible that the student was incubating an URTI at the time of the examination. Other possible infections, such as COVID, were ruled out. An appeal was made based on the possible association between incubating an URTI and unusually poor examination performance.
Results: The appeal was supported by the adjudicating committee and the student was allowed a place in the preferred secondary school.
Conclusions: This case study shows that information about the association between URTIs and mental performance can be used as an extenuating circumstance that can plausibly account for poor academic performance. This can form the basis of the future appeals and recommendations for the type of evidence needed to make such claims are made.
Relevance for Patients: URTIs are frequent, common, and a cause of absence from education and work. They may also impair performance, with effects not being restricted to the time the person is symptomatic. They may also increase susceptibility to the negative effects of stress and fatigue.
[1] Smith AP. Twenty-Five Years of Research on the Behavioural Malaise Associated with Influenza and the Common Cold. Psychoneuroendocrinology 2013;38:744-51.
[2] Smith AP. Respiratory Virus Infections and Performance. Philos Trans R Soc London B Biol Sci 1990;327:519-28.
[3] Smith AP, Tyrrell DA, Coyle K, Willman JS. Selective Effects of Minor Illnesses on Human Performance. Br J
Psychol 1987;78:183-8.
[4] Smith AP, Tyrrell DA, Al-Nakib W, Coyle KB, Donovan CB, Higgins PG, et al. Effects of Experimentally Induced Respiratory Virus Infections and Illnesses on Psychomotor Performance. Neuropsychobiology 1987;18:144-8.
[5] Smith AP, Tyrrell DA, Al-Nakib W, Coyle KB, DonovanCB, Higgins PG, et al. The Effects of Experimentally Induced Respiratory Virus Infections on Performance. Psychol Med 1988;18:65-71.
[6] Smith AP, Tyrrell DA, Al-Nakib W, Barrow GI, Higgins PG, Leekam S, et al. Effects and after-effects of
the Common Cold and Influenza on Human Performance. Neuropsychobiology 1989;21:90-3.
[7] Smith AP, Thomas M, Brockman P, Kent J, Nicholson KG. Effect of Influenza B Virus Infection on Human
Performance. Br Med J 1993;306:760-1.
[8] Smith A, Thomas M, Kent J, Nicholson K. Effects of the Common Cold on Mood and Performance.
Psychoneuroendocrinology 1998;23:733-9.
[9] Smith AP. Effects of Upper Respiratory Tract Illness and Stress on Alertness and Reaction Time. Psychoneuroendocrinology 2013;38:2003-9.
[10] Smith AP. Fatigue, Susceptibility to the Common Cold and its Behavioural Effects. Med Res Arch 2021;9:1-14.
[11] Smith A. Effects of the Common Cold on Simulated Driving. In: Bust, PD, editor. Contemporary Ergonomics. London:Taylor & Francis; 2006. p. 621-4.
[12] Smith AP, Jamson SL. An Investigation of the Effects of the Common Cold on Simulated Driving Performance and Detection of Collisions: A Laboratory Study. BMJ Open 2012;2:e001047.
[13] Grant J. Post-influenzal Judgement Deflection among Scientific Personnel. Asian J Med 1972;8:535-9.
[14] Nichol KL, D’Heilly S, Ehlinger E. Burden of Upper Respiratory Illnesses among College and University
Students: 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 Cohorts. Vaccine 2006;24:6724-5.
[15] Public Health England Syndromic Surveillance Summary 2021 Week 36. Available from: https://www.assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1017940/PHESyndromicSurveillanceSummary2021Week36.pdf