The Effects of Agricultural Water Pricing Policies on the Sustainability of the Water Resources: A Case of Irrigation Network in Qazvin Plain
Qazvin plain in Iran is one of the most fertile regions for crop production, but it has been suffering from severe crises in water resources, inefficient water allocation, and improper cropping pattern due to low tariffs in recent years. One influential policy in the context of sustainable water resource management is suitable pricing. Given the legal potentials and technical conditions for the adoption of various pricing policies, the present paper addresses the effect of area, volumetric or two-part tariff pricing policies with the scenarios of pricing by water supply cost, economic value, or residual value of water on economic variables and water use rate. To this end, positive mathematical programming method was adopted and the data were collected through a questionnaire from the farmers served by the irrigation network of Qazvin plain. Also, experts’ opinions were collected and a library study was conducted. The results show that area pricing policy has no impact on water use management in crops irrigated with sprinkler or flood systems and increased water use by as high as 72% in alfalfa farms irrigated by flood system. Volumetric policy and two-part tariff policy reduces water use by as high as 45% in most cropping systems with various irrigation technologies and encourages farmers to use sprinkler or tape irrigation technologies. However, given the negative economic impacts of these pricing policies on local farming, it is imperative to offset their adverse impacts by alternative policies that can improve water resource sustainability and at the same time, do not cause fluctuations in economic interests of users.
Azimifard, S., Zare Mehrjardi, M. and H. Mehrabi Basharabadi (2013). Sustainability of water resources in Quchan County: Fractional programming approach. Journal of Agricultural Science and Sustainable Production, 23(3): 1-11. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Bagheri, A., Nikouei, A.R., Khodadad Kashi, F. and M. ShokatFadaei (2017). Evaluation of Water Pricing Policy on Aquifer Stability and preservation: Study of Northern Mahyar Plain Aquifer in Zayandeh-Rud Basin. Journal of Economics and Agricultural Development, 31(2): 105-120. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Bakhshi, A., Daneshvar Kakhki, M. and R. Moghaddasi (2011). An application of positive mathematical programming model to analyze the effects of alternative policies on water pricing in Mashhad plain. Agricultural Economics & Development, 25(3): 284-294. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Berbel, J., Viaggi, D. and B. Manos (2009). Estimating demand for irrigation water in European Mediterranean countries through MCDM models. Water Policy, 11(3): 348-361.
Borimnejad, V. and S. Yazdani (2004). Sustainability analysis in water resources management in agricultural sector using fractional programming. Case study: Kerman province. Pajouhesh & Sazandegi, 63: 2-16. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Cai, X., McKinney, D.C. and M.W. Rosegrant (2003). Sustainability analysis for irrigation water management in the Aral Sea region. Agricultural System, 76: 1043-1066.
Cortignani, R. and S. Severini (2009). Modeling farm-level adoption of deficit irrigation using Positive Mathematical Programming. Agricultural Water Management, 96: 1785-1791.
Easter, K.W. (1999). The transition of irrigation management in Asia: Have we turned the corner yet? Paper presentation, 6th conference of the international water and resource economics consortium, Hawaii.
Gallego-Ayala, J. and J.A. Gómez-Limón (2009). Analysis of policy instruments for control of nitrate pollution in irrigated agriculture in Castillay León, Spain. Spanish Journal of Agricultural Research, 7(1): 24-40.
Gallego-Ayala, J. (2012). Selecting irrigation water pricing alternatives using a multimethodological approach. Mathematical and Computer Modelling, 55: 861-883.
Gómez-Limón, J.A. and L. Riesgo (2004). Irrigation water pricing: Differential impacts on irrigated farms. Agricultural Economic, 31(1): 47-66.
Gujarati, D. (1995). Basic Econometrics (3rd ed., Vol. I). (H. Abrishami, Trans.) Tehran, Iran: Tehran University Press. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Hezareh, R. (2013). A study on the economic, social and environmental impacts in irrigation water pricing using multicriteria approach in Qazvin plain (M.Sc. Thesis). Tehran, Iran: Tarbiat Moddarress University Press. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Hosseinpour Talebi, S. (2016). An economic study on rice cropping pattern in Mazandaran province with an emphasis on ratoon planting: The application of PMP in the case of Amol County (M.Sc. Thesis). Tehran, Iran: Department of Agricultural Economics and Development, Tehran University Press. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Iglesias, E. and M. Blanco (2008). New directions in water resources management: The role of water-pricing policies. Water Resource Research, 44: W06417.
Istiaque, H., Mahmudul, A., Chamhuri, S. and M. Mazin (2016). Measurement of water productivity in seasonal flood plain Beel area. Asian Journal of Water, Environment and pollution, 13(2): 1-14.
Jamali Moghaddam, A. (2016). Assessment of economic and environmental sustainability of the agricultural sector in Fars province (M.Sc. Thesis). Tehran: Department of Agricultural Economics and Development, Tehran University Press. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Kavousi Akbaripour, Z. (2013). The selection of irrigation water pricing alternative using an integrated positive mathematical programming and multicriteria decision- making approach (M.Sc. Thesis). Zabol, Iran: Zabol University Press. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Lynam, J.K. and R.W. Herdt (1989). Sense and Sustainability: Sustainability as an Objective in International Agricultural Research. Agricultural Economics, 3: 381-398.
Medellin-Azuara J., Howitt, R. and J. Harou (2012). Predicting farmer responses to water pricing, rationing and subsidies assuming profit maximizing investment in irrigation technology. Agricultural Water Management,
108: 73-82.
Mousavi, S. and F. Gharghani (2009). Calculating agricultural water sustainability indexes by fractional programming model (The case study in Marvdasht). Agricultural Economics, 3(3): 143-160. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Parhizkari, A., Sabouhi, M., Ahmadpour, M. and H. Badi Barzin (2014). Simulation of farmers’ response to irrigation water pricing and rationing policies (Case study: Zabol city). Agricultural Economics & Development,
28(2): 164-176. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Raghavendra, S., Pardhasaradhi, S. and S. Suram (2017). A Case Study on Sustainable Development in Coal India Limited. Asian Journal of Water, Environment and Pollution, 14(3): 57-63.
Rahnama, A., Kohansal, M. and A. Dourandish (2013). Estimating the economic value of water using positive mathematical programming in Quchan city. Agricultural Economics, 6(4): 127-146. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Shankayi, R. (2016). A study on the impacts of the governmental policies on cropping pattern in different utilization systems in Tehran province (M.Sc. Thesis). Tehran, Iran: Department of Agricultural Economics and Development, Tehran University Press. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Shannon, C.E. (1948). A Mathematical Theory of Communication. Bell System Technical Journal, 27: 379-423.
Speelman, S., Buysse, J., Farolfi, S., Frija, A., D’Haese, D. and L. D’Haese (2009). Estimating the impacts of water pricing on smallholder irrigators in North West Province, South Africa. Agricultural Water Management, 96: 1560- 1566.
Vaziri, A., Vakilpour, M. and S. Mortazavi (2016). The effects of economic pricing of irrigation water on cropping pattern in the Dehgolan plain. Journal of Agricultural Economics Research, 8(31): 81-100. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Water Research Institute (2008). A study on unofficial agricultural water market in a region as a pilot: Final report. Iran’s Water Resources Management Company. (In Persian with English Abstract)
Wichelns, D. and J.D. Oster (2006). Sustainable irrigation is necessary and achievable, but direct costs and environmental impacts can be sustainable. Agricultural Water Management, 86: 114-127.
Yazdani, S., Mohamadian, F., Taheri, O. and S. Kalhori (2016). Defining sustainability indicators and improving productivity of resources production in cropping pattern in Mahidasht Plain, Kermanshah province (fractional programming approach. Agricultural Economics, 10(1): 115-136. (In Persian with English Abstract)