A Comparative Study of Neural networks and Fuzzy Systems in Modeling of a Nonlinear Dynamic System
The aim of this paper is to compare the neural networks and fuzzy modeling approaches on a nonlinear system. We have taken Permanent Magnet Brushless Direct Current (PMBDC) motor data and have generated models using both approaches. The predictive performance of both methods was compared on the data set for model configurations. The paper describes the results of these tests and discusses the effects of changing model parameters on predictive and practical performance. Modeling sensitivity was used to compare for two methods.
[1] N. Selvaganesan and R. Saraswathy Ramya, A Simple Fuzzy Modeling of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Generator,Elektrika, vol. 11, no. 1, 38-43, (2009)
[2] K.J.Astrom, C.C.Hang, P.Persson, and W.K.Ho, Towards Intelligent PID Control, Automatica, vol. 28, no. 1, 1-9,(1992)
[3] Saleem R.M., and Poslethwaite B.F., A comparison of neural networks and fuzzy relational systems in dynamic modeling, control‟94, IEE, no.389, 1448-1452,(1994)
[4] Metin Demirtas, Off-line tuning of a PI speed controller for a permanent magnet brushless DC motor using DSP, Energy Conversion and Management 52, 264–273,(2011)
[5] Zhang Bo, Li Zhong and Mao Zong Yuan, A type of fuzzy modeling of the chaotic system of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor, IEEE Conf., pp 880-883.
[6] Jacek Kabzifski, Fuzzy modeling of disturbance torques/forces in rotational/linear interior permanent magnet synchronous motors, Proc. On EPE, 1-10, (2005)
[7] S.Yamamoto and I. Hashimoto, “Present status and future needs: the view from Japanese industry. Chemical Process control”, Proceedings of the fourth international conf. on chemical process control, TX, (1991)
[8] Y. Wang and H. Shao, Optimal tuning for PI controller, Automatica, 36, 147-152, (2000)
[9] TECHNOFOFT DSP Motion Solutions, MxWIN243 User Manuel, Switzerland, (2001)
[10] Cybenko G., “Approximation by superpositions of a sigmoidal function”, Math. Control Signal Syst., 303-314, (1989)
[11] Girosi., F., and Poggio., T., Networks and the best approximation property, Biol. Cybernetics, 169-179,(1990)
[12] Park., J., and Sandberg, I.W., Universal approximation using radial basis function networks, Neur. Comput., 246-257,(1991)
[13] Ustun SV, Demirtas M, Optimal tuning of PI speed controller coefficients for electric drives using neural networks and genetic algorithms, Electrical Engineering, vol. 87, No:2, 77-82, (2005)
[14] Krishnan R., Election Criteria for Servo Motor Drives, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, vol.M-23 no.2, 270-275, (1987)
[15] G. R. Slemon, Electric Machines and Drives, Addison-Wesley Publication Company, 503– 511, (1992)
